apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Green Bottled Water?

water101708.jpgCan bottled water be green?

 
 

Icelandic Glacial claims to be the world’s first certified carbon-neutral bottled water. We’re addicted to our tap filter and Sigg, but there are times when we’re out and about, thirsty, and do wind up purchasing a bottle of H20.

So is this water really green?

The plant is powered entirely on hydro-electric power, which we love. However, other green factors cited include that the plastic bottle can be recycled and that because Iceland imports most products, the bottled water that is exported takes advantage of what would otherwise be empty cargo slots.

What do you think?

Tags

air & water quality

Related Links

Share

Comments (4)

Just because something can be recycled does not mean it is "green." Are the bottles made from recycled plastic? I'd bet not. Likely they are made from virgin plastic. The plastic bottles that do get recycled (and many will end up in the ocean or in landfills) may be downcycled into another plastic product which will likely not be recyclable. So really the virgin plastic used to make these plastic bottles will eventually end up in landfills anyway. This is just another example of greenwashing.

posted by The Green Cat on November 18th 2008 at 12:07pm
view The Green Cat's profile

i think a better option (when your sigg/nalgene/water glass isn't available) is water in compostable bottles. tho you'll have to make sure to compost it obviously.

biota and primo makes these, and there are likely others.

posted by fivealive1969 on November 18th 2008 at 3:28pm
view fivealive1969's profile

Can bottled water be green? No

posted by labchick on November 18th 2008 at 9:32pm
view labchick's profile

Can bottled water be green? In a word, no. But define green...yada yada.

Are there alternatives that will use less energy (says common sense, not a complicated LSA) and create less waste? Yes! Buy a reusable water bottle, and use it daily.

If you're out and about and your reusable bottle is bone dry, don't feel guilty about buying one bottle of water...it's the frequent, daily habits that make a difference!

posted by enviromodernist on November 21st 2008 at 2:59am
view enviromodernist's profile