Wanna?
On Wednesday, we posted a book review of Cadillac Desert that originally came from AT: Kitchen. Then, Pixie commented: I wonder if there's some way we can book-club it on this site?
We were intrigued. An AT: Green Home book club ... Why not? It sounds like fun to us, and there are so many books we've been meaning to read.
So we're curious: If we started a book club here in a week or so, would you be interested in participating? This would entail reading the book and participating in some sort of weekly online discussion (probably in the comment section).
We're already trying to imagine how we'll incorporate wine or coffee into this equation. It could be tough ... but, doesn't a good book club need one or the other?
Also, do you have any book suggestions?
These are a few potential titles we've come up with so far:
• Cadillac Desert (obviously) by Marc Reisner
• Animal, Vegetable, Miracle by Barbara Kingsolver
• Cradle to Cradle by William McDonough and Michael Braungart
• The Philosophy of Sustainable Design by Jason F. McLennan
What do you think?
We're kind of excited. We've never done anything like this on an AT site, but we think it could be a good time.
Beautiful bookshelf image: Via zoom in tight; flickr.com
I'd be interested. Though it would seem like this would be better off as a monthly thing since it takes a while to read...
view dahlia's profile
Interested, and second the "monthly" (or even bi-monthly) idea.
Book suggestion: The Omnivore's Dilemma, Michael Pollan
view Lissa's profile
Oops
I didn't mean to imply that we'd be reading the entire book in a week (I'm much too slow for that). I think we'd read the book over the course of a month or two but maybe have small comment-based discussions once a week or once every other week.
Should have phrased that one better!
Thanks for the interest and consider Omnivore's Dilemma on the list.
view StephanieK's profile
I think this is a great idea...I've been wanting to read more and this would give me some direction and motivation!
view Beth H's profile
I'm in. I've been meaning to read that Pollan book for ages.
view mmadden's profile
I'm in, as I'm two-thirds through the Omnivore's Dilemma right now. A great choice for a book club, especially since it's now available in paperback.
view Michelle of Montreal's profile
I'm in. I just read Plenty: One Man, One Woman, and a Raucous Year of Eating Locally, by Alisa Smith and J.B. Mackinnon. I'd be up for Animal, Vegetable, Miracle by Barbara Kingsolver.
view Green Me's profile
I would be into this but I really have very little interest with regards to Pollan -- I've read enough criticisms to know I'd be in that boat -- but I'd be into the rest of the suggestions.
view jesse@humanerecipe's profile
I'm in. I think this is a fabulous idea!
view ebrown's profile
I like the idea, though it will be a struggle to read just one book a month, much less weekly.
I have had Cadillac Desert on my to read list since it was originally published. This will give me the kick in the butt i need to actually read it. Yipes, I have been moving it around with me for how many years?
view Grace2's profile
I'm in in general --definitely for Cadillac Desert -- but reserve the right to be temporarily "out" if I know a book is going to motivate me to nitpick every detail and just plain be annoying to know.
view wende in the twin cities's profile
jesse and wende - Naysayers and skeptics make book clubs interesting! There's nothing more boring than a bunch of people cooing, "Ooh what a great book, the author's a genius, blah blah blah." If you hate the book so much you don't want to finish it, we'll understand, but I'm sure you'll have a lot to contribute to the discussion of books you didn't like.
view mmadden's profile
I second waterreflecting's suggestion of Plenty!
view midnightskyfibers's profile
I would love to participate in a book club, and I would like to second the suggestion of The Omnivore's Dilemma.
view raxxq's profile
I too would love to participate - and I "third" The Omnivore's Dilemma. Let's do it!
view mbinaustin's profile
I wrote the original review of Cadillac Desert and I must say it is FASCINATING but it took me a while to get through. Couple months at least. However, a lot of the chapters stand alone pretty well, and if anyone would just like to cherry pick a couple chapters I could give some recommendations.
Also, it's less "nitpicky" on a local level, and more a story-driven account of the entire history of the Western United States, told through water.
view faith's profile
I think this is a great idea and would also be up for discussing Omnivore's Dilemma and/or Animal, Vegetable, Miracle--I've already read both, and have Plenty on my hold list at the library.
view erin79's profile
This is an awesome idea and if I were not in the middle of a doc program I would definitely participate. I hope this goes well and I can participate in 3-5 years :-)
view classiccook's profile
I'm in! Cadillac Desert first, please--it's been on my shelf for too long and I really want to read it!
view Pixie's profile
Another title I'm intrigued by is The Empty Ocean. There are only a handful of reviews on Amazon of it, so I wonder if it's very well read. Anyone know anything about it?
view Pixie's profile
I suggest 'The Omnivore's Dilemma' by Michael Pollan. Great food read and sort of goes along with Kingsolver and the Plenty book by Smith and Mackinnon.
view fingrrrl's profile
Also, anything by Bill McKibben and/or Naomi Klein. Hmmm...now I'm going from green to purely political.
view fingrrrl's profile
Oops, Omnivore's Dilemma has already been suggested. How about anything by Joel Salatin. He was the 'grass' farmer featured in Omnivore's Dilemma.
view fingrrrl's profile
I would be interested and I agree with monthly.
view Jeanne's profile
i love it. my real-life book club just discussed "animal, vegetable, miracle" at our last meeting. it made for a really interesting discussion and one our least off-topic discussions to date - probably b/c we were all so interested in the book. i was also able to bring up "the omnivore's dilemma" (as mentioned by everybody else!) b/c i just finished reading that few months ago.
it's not coffee or wine, but we do potluck lunches. this past meeting, we each made a dish made with local food. (still not sure how to translate that idea to the at book club though!)
view gretchenalexis's profile
This sounds fun. I've already read Omnivore's Dilemma and Cradle to Cradle-both great. Animal, Vegetable, Miracle is on my list, as is Everything I Want to do is Illegal by Joel Saletan (mentioned above), The World Without Us, and one called Organic, Inc.
There's also oldies but goodies, like Fast Food Nation and Silent Spring.
view deoxy's profile
This sounds like a great idea. Goes right along with my book group readings. Let's do it - monthly.
view joann's profile
I would recommend Victor Papanek's (early!) text on green design issues, _Design for the Real World: Human Ecology and Social Change_.
there's so many more books to recommend, but since this is a green design site--plus i feel this book is a neglected classic.
It's also fun to read b/c Papanek is a bit of a curmudgeon, in a good way.
view edgertor's profile