
(Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first. Email questions and pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to: green(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com)
Sam writes:
I love Febreze fabric refreshers, but I'd like something a little more earth friendly. Can anyone recommend an eco-friendly alternative, or a good home recipe for one. Something antibacterial would be great. Thanks!
Sam, this is a good question.
We're assuming you're referring to Febreze Fabric Refresher, not the line of air fresheners that are also sold under the Febreze name.
Our opinion on Febreze Fabric Refresher is that it's not any worse than green commercial cleaning products such as Mrs. Meyer's: that is, its main environmental impact comes from the fact that it's primarily water, which is heavy, and it's trucked around the country in plastic bottles.
The main ingredient in Febreze is called cyclodextrin, and as chemicals go, it's not that scary. A chemist friend who once worked for P&G explained that it's basically a sticky ring -- we like to imagine it's a very, very small donut. It's made from corn, but in the same way that ethanol is made from corn; it's refined and very far removed from the source.
Each element in the ring is designed to grab on to different kinds of molecules associated with odor. Once that happens, the ring becomes too heavy to float in the air and it falls to ground, where one of those sticky elements in the ring latches it on to the carpet or bedspread that you're freshening. So: Febreze works by making things dirtier!
Now for the alternatives:
- Air fresheners, for the most part, are out, though some like Method's products.
- If it's carpet you're trying to freshen, you can make a powder, but you'll still have to vacuum.
- Or, if you're in an rented apartment, washing the walls and hidden places like the top of kitchen cabinets with a solution of vinegar or a green cleaner such as CleanVia can help eliminate stale smells from the previous tenant's pack-a-day habit, diet high in fried foods, or both.
- Another alternative is an air purifier. You won't be using any chemicals at all, but the ongoing energy use offsets the savings.
We're not big fans of
antibacterial products -- keeping things dry and relatively clean is the healthiest thing for your house and yourself.
Readers, any other alternatives to Febreze? We'd love to know of a home brew that works in the same way...
image of Febreze via Febreze web site; cyclodextrin diagram via scienceinthebox.com as linked above
A simple home made air freshener can be made with
an essential oil of your choice, distilled water and clear alcohol such as vodka. 10 drops of essential oil, mixed into a spray bottle with 1/2 distilled water and 1/2 vodka. (the vodka keeps
the essential oil from evaporating.)
Smells great, all natural, no harmful chemicals....
view houndhouse's profile
You could also eat less beans.
view joebelt's profile
I guess it depends on what you're "refreshing". I'm guessing it's not something launderable, or you would just clean it that way. If it's your car, I'd try using baking soda and a good vacuum to get rid of musty odors. Same with furniture, I guess. However, some things are destined to be funky, like my boyfriend's hockey gear. That we just spray with Febreze Anti-Bacterial and hope for the best.
Is Febreze really that environmentall unfriendly? It doesn't seem to be washed down the drain and it's not in aerosol form...
view leanneabe's profile
My husband is severely allergic to Febreze. Even though he doesn't have asthma, he begins wheezing and has trouble catching his breath. I am not a scientist, so I don't know if it is the scent that affects him or not. He doesn't have this problem with any thing else.
I switched to using essential oil and vinegar for all my scent absorbing needs, if it can handle liquid. If it can't get wet, I use dryer sheets to help. But if something is really in need of freshening, drag it out on the lawn on a sunny breezy day.
view K8 in Maine's profile
I recommend checking out essential oil websites or vendors because they will teach you proper dilutions of oils that can be used for refreshing fabrics or diffusing to refresh a room. I know that I use diluted tea tree oil and while it maybe smells like the oil for a few hours, all the odor is gone not too long after, you could mix other oils like lavender or rose if you wanted to have a fragrance...if you are looking to disinfect or diffuse the air, Thieves or young living's purification are excellent oils that have been around for hundreds of years and are still commonly used. I diffused thieves when I moved into my apartment to refresh the walls and carpet. Worked like a charm and smells wonderful. Other oils can be found at any co-op or organic market. I think essential oils is a common brand?
view Geri's profile
oops, I mean Aura Cacia essential oils is a commonly found brand, though I do recommend Young Living. It is just sometimes harder to find.
view Geri's profile
When I worked in wardrobe, we just used vodka and water, 1/2 and 1/2 to spray on the costumes. I started using it at home. For my fabrics I put a few drops of ceder oil in the mix, I have found that it repels bugs and moths away from curtains and closets. Also, the cheaper the vodka the better!
view kgoodman80's profile
An old theatre trick for costumes is a combination of 1/2 really cheap vodka and 1/2 water. I use this on my curtains and upholstered furniture at my house and it works great.
view scarab1's profile
What is the upside/advantage to using vodka and water over Febreeze?
I don't really Febreeze anymore now that there is no smoking in bars...just curious really.
view Marie's profile
I use the Stonewall Kitchen Lavender Mint linen/room refresher. It is nice and light. I have terrible allergies to febreeze, but have not had any reactions to the Stonewall stuff. I also use their hand soaps, and love their soy candles.
http://www.stonewallkitchen.com/prdsell.aspx?L0=LavenderMintFineHomekeepingProducts
view Sharon H's profile
While I'm ticked to finally find out how Febreeze works (I'm your target audience for fifth grader-level scientific explanations), *anything* made by Proctor & Gamble is decidedly un-green by most definitions. They're still one of the largest users of animal testing, and purchasing/using products from a company that's responsible for genetically engineering, breeding and destroying millions of lab animals each year is not what I'd consider eco-friendly.
view AMLitt's profile
Well, if you consider animals to be part of the environment (I do), than anything that tests on animals is environmentally unfriendly. And Febreze tests on animals, so it is not an option in my home.
view zhasmene's profile