apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Question: Greener Swiffer?

8_9_2007-noswiffer.jpg
Just this morning, AT:Green Home reader Shanalee wrote in:

I have 2 cats and a dog. I Swiffer probably 3 or 4 times a week... that's a LOT of Swiffer refills! Any green alternatives?
-shanalee


Dear Shanalee,
By our calculations, you are spending about $1 per week, or $52 per year, on Swiffer refills, which means that over the next 5 years, you'll spend upwards of $250 on something you'll throw away.
Your email hinted that you are aware that Swiffer refills are not biodegradable, so it's not just a matter of money.
Here are 3 ideas for you, in increasing order of cost:

 
 
8_9_2007-bona-mophead.jpg

Option 1: An old-fashioned dust mop, like this one from Bona. (We've blogged Bona before over at AT:Chicago, with links to places to purchase aside from Amazon.) Because you clean so often, you should buy a bunch—on our laundry cycle it would take 8—and just toss them in the washing machine. Total cost: about $63.

8_9_2007-furminator.jpg

Option 2: Add to dust mop: The Furminator. PT Barnum-style website aside, our extremely neat friends with pets swear by this pet shedding brush. Cost: around $50 for the large, plus a couple dust mops; it eliminates almost all of the shedding, but you'll still find a few stray pet hairs.

8_9_2007-roomba.jpg

Option 3: If you're lazy (or is it realistic?) like us, grooming your pet every couple days just doesn't happen, which makes this last option the most appealing to us. At $300 and up, the new Roomba for Pets is certainly the most expensive option, and you'll still need to empty the dust bin, but the idea of a fur-free house with almost no work is really appealing to us.

AT:Green Home readers with pets: what's your advice? Has anyone tried the Roomba for Pets? Previous Roombas had a reputation for choking on pet hair...

Tags

Good Questions, pets, cleaning

Related Links

Share

Comments (23)

I have a similar situation. I have used my Eureka vaccuum broom and it picks up most of the dog hair....not all. I brush the dog a couple of times a week. I have tried MicroPlus type of products, as suggested. NOTHING works as well as the Swifter in picking up all of the dog hair. However, I use both sides of the swifter and after I go over my floors I use the vaccuum to clean the dog hair off of the Swifter. I know I am creating trash that is not biodegradable....but using the Swifter as long as I can cuts down on that. If I find some thing that works as well as the Swifter, I will switch but until then, it is the Swifter.

posted by Mason on 2007-08-09 15:21:34
view Mason's profile

Method's new omop is a green version of the Swiffer; it's great!

http://methodhome.com/products.php?cat=type&type=omop&prod=starter_kit

posted by Victoria E on 2007-08-09 15:34:32
view Victoria E's profile

thanks! this helps a lot!

we're a family who doesn't use paper towels, paper plates, plastic bags, etc. everytime i pull a swiffer cloth out of the box i cringe!

posted by shanalee on 2007-08-09 15:40:15
view shanalee's profile

The final solution is to purchase a swiffer cozy which is a knitted cover for your swiffer. It picks up all the animal hair and dust and is machine-washable! Email at christine@aperfectbag.com and I will email you a photo and price. x0x0

posted by just a grrll from bklyn on 2007-08-09 15:42:41
view just a grrll from bklyn's profile

I bought some washable swiffer covers on E-bay. They were hand-made. This way you don't have to throw away your swiffer if you already have it. They work REALLY well.

posted by J-fer Rose on 2007-08-09 15:54:06
view J-fer Rose's profile

my mom has a broom that has rubber bristles and it squeegees hair off the floor. it's AWESOME i love it so much i almost (not quite) look forward to sweeping her house.

posted by elizabeth in AL on 2007-08-09 16:02:51
view elizabeth in AL's profile

My hairdresser uses one of those rubber-bristled brooms.

posted by Joan A. on 2007-08-09 16:35:34
view Joan A.'s profile

the omop is great. you can get a washable microfiber cloth for cleaning floors and their "swiffer" cloths are compostable

posted by vertigo on 2007-08-09 16:58:58
view vertigo's profile

The omop swiffer cloths are compostable, but they don't pick up pet fur like Swiffer cloths do (with 3 dogs and 2 cats, I've done fur-pick-up testing). The washable cloth for the mop, though, is good at cleaning the floors and will "sweep" most of the fur into it.

The regular Roomba does choke on pet har. I have to cut it off every time it runs, which kind of defeats the point of having an easy robot vacuum. I'm curious how the Pet version is better. Hmm... it looks like there's a brush upgrade if you already have a Roomba and don't want to buy the new Pet one. I'm definitely going to try that one out.
http://store.irobot.com/product/index.jsp?productId=2447112

Don't spend $50 on the Furminator. Go to a pet shop and buy a $6 shedding blade or curry comb. It's practically the same thing and gets more of the undercoat than the Furminator. Trust me - you'll be there for hours wondering how much more fun you could possibly get off one animal. And then wondering how one dog can produce so much fur and not be bald.

posted by leanneabe on 2007-08-09 19:05:48
view leanneabe's profile

I just take a bar towel or rag and swiffer with that ... no need to buy new products and washable!

posted by apointe on 2007-08-10 09:49:57
view apointe's profile

I have three dogs and my entire house has hardwood floors, so I have my share of dog hair too. I use a dustmop that I bought from Target for like $10 and it works wonderfully.

posted by JohnnySlimane on 2007-08-10 11:33:52
view JohnnySlimane's profile

I have to chime in and say that I've been using the Furminator on my cats and I'm a total convert! They love it and it gets off waaaaaay more than the other combs and brushes we own.

posted by CMcB on 2007-08-10 11:42:40
view CMcB's profile

hey joan a - do you know where to get one? my mom doesn't remember and i want to steal it from her. but she won't let me.

posted by elizabeth in AL on 2007-08-10 11:55:56
view elizabeth in AL's profile

I started using cut flannel cloths on my Swiffer - they sell them as rags at HomeDepot/Lowes at something like 12/$6. You can just clip the fabric right into the Swiffer and toss them in the wash.

I am very interested in that Furminator!

posted by jesse@humanerecipe on 2007-08-10 12:34:40
view jesse@humanerecipe's profile

Why not shave them?
;0)

posted by chris_94131 on 2007-08-10 16:17:58
view chris_94131's profile

elizabeth in AL -- I'll try to remember to ask her.

posted by Joan A. on 2007-08-11 22:02:38
view Joan A.'s profile

elizabeth in AL --

Is it the carpet rake?

http://www.shophometrends.com/product.asp_Q_pn_E_020011

posted by RJD on 2007-08-11 22:04:57
view RJD's profile

I have a Furminator-like brush, and it does work as advertised...on one of my cats. I can't use it on the other one because he bites me after the first couple of strokes. Evil beast.

As far as removing pet hair from my floors, I prefer to vacuum once a week. I'm not sure where that fits in the heirarchy of greenness though. I mean, it uses electricity, but there's no rags to throw out, and I would probably vacuum once a week anyway even if I didn't have cats.

posted by margie on 2007-08-12 09:12:08
view margie's profile

elizabeth in AL-

The one I use is the FURemover: http://www.stacksandstacks.com/html/11243_furemover-broom-sweep-away-messes-with-the-power-of-rubber.htm

posted by mo p on 2007-08-13 01:21:43
view mo p's profile

not the carpet rake - more like the FURemover, but smaller in width with blue bristles and white plastic where the bristles come out - i think - but i know it has blue/navy bristles - the FURemover seems like a better version - the other one is so small it takes me half an hour to sweep the living room - I'm going to buy one pronto - our 2 puppies came home this weekend!!!

posted by elizabeth in AL on 2007-08-13 10:10:18
view elizabeth in AL's profile

After reading the posts here, my boyfriend (who has a dog, a cat and a *very* small apartment) and I stumbled across a FURminator knock off at Bed, Bath and Beyond for $15.00. We figured "what the hell", bought it and tried it out on his black lab right there in the parking lot. Holy Crap, it was amazing!

When we got home, we finished up the lab and got a good start on the cat. Cat didn't like it, but we found that putting him in a high-sided bucket with just enough room so he didn't feel so restrained worked really well.

posted by Maryja on 2007-08-13 14:35:48
view Maryja's profile

this is the reason I don't have pets.

posted by Sol on 2007-08-13 15:14:37
view Sol's profile

Why. On God's green earth. Does anyone have 3 dogs in the home?!?!??!?!

It boggles the mind!

posted by clickchick on 2007-08-13 22:10:11
view clickchick's profile