apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Don't Buy Green
GOOD Magazine's blog 5.7.09

5-9-2009header2green-receipt-art2.jpg

We talk a lot here about buying green — both directly and indirectly — and green consumerism. We think about it a lot and, naturally, we're always pleased to read a thoughtful take on the topic ...

 
 

There's an interesting post up over at GOOD magazine's blog on the topic of buying green — and their opinion is, essentially, that it's not really doing us any good right now.

We agree, with some caveats. The kind of green consumerism that GOOD seems to be talking about is what we'll call "extraneous green consumerism." Example: Buying a bamboo T-shirt you don't need is not better than just forgoing the T-shirt altogether. We'll totally agree with that one. The habit of consuming just to consume is what we need to get over.

However, there's another type of green consumerism that we're 100% behind, and that's a smarter green consumerism. Example: When you run out of dish soap, buying a "green" bottle of dish soap to replace it. Or buying a bunch of awesome kitchen cloths from Trader Joe's so that you can stop buying paper towels.

How do you feel about the topic? And how do you keep yourself in the "smart green consumer" column?

(Image: GOOD)

Tags

greenwash, green consumerism

Related Links

Share

Comments (7)

I would have to agree that buying things is not a way out of an environmental crisis. However, the change in the way we live has to start somewhere. The small steps of buying recycled and recyclable goods ( Recycled binders or paper www.naked binder.com, www.newleafpaper.com...), reusable goods ( kitchen cloths, reusable water bottles www.mysigg.com...) and more environmentally friendly products (bamboo, local organic produce...). do make a difference.

They also train us to think about these things. Once we start thinking differently about consumption, real change can be made.

posted by flippercrutch on May 11th 2009 at 11:19am
view flippercrutch's profile

Tough question. When looking for the answer where should we start? We could start with the individual consumer or we could start with government and industry.

On the industrial level, it seems like going green is a good way to create jobs. We need jobs, but do we need million dollar windmills? It's possible the windmills may make a positive environmental difference some day but in the short term, someone has gotten a contract and tax incentives to build it. Of course, I don't really know what I'm talking about while playing devil's advocate.

On a personal level, I think that buying something "green" is a nice alternative to have. For instance, I just purchased some lightweight composite pavers for my balcony. This product is, aesthetically and functionally, exactly what I want.

It just so happens, it is made out of 90 percent recycled materials. So, I "needed" to consume and the perfect choice was a "green" product. This is the type of product innovation that I hope our country will become known for in the future. At the end of the day we are still capitalists.

posted by art on May 11th 2009 at 11:48am
view art's profile

I think that green consumerism is a great thing. While being eco-friendly may not be feasible all the time due to financial restraints, we can all chip in and do our part in other small, inexpensive ways. For example, things such as not letting the water run when we're preparing to jump in the shower or brush our teeth, recycling and trying to use household cleaners that are just as efficient minus all of those chemicals...

posted by LightsOnline on May 11th 2009 at 12:26pm
view LightsOnline's profile

And a quick note about bamboo used for clothing, towels, etc... caustic chemicals are used to turn the bamboo into fabrics. Those are very bad for the environment. Better choices for fabrics are organic cotton, wool, silk & hemp. Look for natural dyes & unbleached fabrics.

posted by tallsarah on May 11th 2009 at 12:49pm
view tallsarah's profile

I think this is something to look out for, at least based on the ridiculous number of reusable fabric shopping bags that I ended up with after purchasing several for myself then receiving them as gifts from family, friends and companies. I'm single and there will never be a shopping trip that I will use all of the dozen or so bags I've acquired. It's nice to have a few extras, but the trunk of my car looked like it was a breeding ground until I started re-gifting them.
When you have a choice green is better than not green, but nothing is better than green.

posted by Rolen the Great on May 11th 2009 at 1:12pm
view Rolen the Great's profile

"When you have a choice green is better than not green, but nothing is better than green."

@Rolen the Great - perfectly put!

posted by Erica in DC on May 11th 2009 at 2:16pm
view Erica in DC's profile

It took me a while to jump aboard the whole "Green" wagon... mostly because a lot of the efforts seemed contrived and consumer-driven. For instance, it still bugs me that some reusable bags are given such a trendy treatment. Aren't we supposed to use them forever, not just until we find a cuter one?

Totally agree on the questionableness of items such as a bamboo t-shirt... just because it's green doesn't mean you need it. Things like buying a water bottle and using a Brita (as opposed to reusing plastic water bottles) is a great idea... very practical. It seems, though, that things are going from less-trendy ideas to more practical. That's the kind of thing I can get behind.

posted by Geno B. on May 11th 2009 at 5:50pm
view Geno B.'s profile