apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Deciphering the Color Rendering Index [CRI]
Or, Why CFLs Still Don't Look All That Good

4_14_2008-colortemp.pngSo you've been good: you used our advice to switch nearly all your bulbs to compact fluorescents. You made sure to get the right color temperature and buy bulbs that come up to full brightness quickly. Your energy bills are down, but somehow your interior has lost a bit of zing. Is it all in your head?

 
 

Color temperature is just half of the equation. Equally important is another number: the Color Rendering Index, or CRI. Daylight and incandescent bulbs set the standard here, with a CRI of 100. That means the human eye perceives all the colors of the spectrum equally well under either daylight or incandescent bulbs.


As for fluorescent bulbs? There's still progress to be made. The best have a CRI of 95. You can think of that as exaggerating some colors -- ours seem to bring out yellows -- while downplaying others, such as blues. This, of course, subtly changes the color palette you perceive in a room.

Unfortunately, while more CFLs are coming with color temperature printed on the base of the bulb or on the packaging, we haven't seen any CRI numbers yet, so it will take a bit of digging to determine which bulbs are better than others.


The bottom line is that all those folks who insist that incandescent bulbs are better than CFLs may have a point: the question is whether the difference is worth using 3 times as much energy.


Illustration by Jonathan Bean using information from the latest issue of Environmental Building News

Tags

lighting, CRI, color rendering index, color temperature, incandescents

Related Links

Share

Comments (2)

I still don't understand the complaints about CFLs. I find the light to be more natural looking than incandescents. They are brighter, yes, but its a more white, natural light and you just have to use fewer lights!

posted by ljh on 2008-04-14 15:37:01
view ljh's profile

honestly my energy bills are not down. just got my bill and am noticing the usage is up from this time last year. i switched almost everything this summer when a bunch of bulbs blew at once - i'm calling my electric company to find out why! i'm very cautious about not wasting electricity and i've got to track down why my usage is up.

posted by Joan in SB on 2008-04-15 14:11:30
view Joan in SB's profile