apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Greening Our Habits, Revisited
Or In This Case, Ladies, a Necessity

09_28_09_ladiesbathroom.jpgOur bathroom cabinet is almost as green as it can be, between the recycled TP and natural fiber washcloths, chemical-free cleaners, and all-natural shampoo. There's one thing, though, that could be even greener. Last year, when this women's-only topic came up, there was an overwhelming response advocating the use of one very green product...

 
 

An overwhelming number of comments on the post I wrote about switching to unbleached organic cotton tampons instead supported something else: the menstrual cup. (For a general explanation, head to Wikipedia.)

Though I'd read all the comments and been mostly persuaded last year, I was a bit nervous about switching and hesitated; in the meantime, I forgot all about this option, honestly, until seeing DivaCups at our local food co-op in the toiletries aisle, and then again at another natural foods store in town. Not to mention, we brought up the topic again on Re-Nest just last week!

Needless to say, I've been doing more research and it adds up: the amount of money spent (and waste created, regardless of whether or not it's organic) buying and using tampons or pads each month instead of an alternative like the menstrual cup or reusable pads makes a significant difference.

We're talking $150 or $200 annually, especially when you factor in the extra cost of buying green feminine products. Consider this: the menstrual cups made from latex, silicone, or TPE are made to last for half a decade or more. At 12 cycles a year, the math is a no-brainer.

Then there were all the helpful tips from readers' comments; here are a few highlights from women who have used them:

• More comfort (There's less drying because the cups don't absorb)
• They can be used at night
• Getting used to wearing them is like learning to wear contacts
• They're an option with more freedom than a pad
• No health risks have been found (Ever been worried about toxic shock syndrome? Not with these...)
• They produce NO trash

I don't know about you, but those factors alone make me want to swap out my organic unbleached tampons for something even more eco-friendly. Not to mention...they sound a bit more comfortable (see point number one).

Anyone else convinced?

Here are a few of the manufacturers (note that not all are available in the States):
DivaCup (US)
The Keeper and Mooncup (US)
Instead Softcups (US)
Lunette (outside US)
MoonCup (UK)

(Image: Flickr member Linda N. licensed under Creative Commons.)

Tags

personal health, Products, Information, bathroom, personal health, toiletries

Related Links

Share

Comments (23)

Got the diva cup a couple of years ago. Best thing ever. No garbage, more convenient (you can wear them a lot longer between changes than a tampon), no health risk, cheaper.

I'll never, ever go back to anything else. They're just to good.

posted by wrenagain on September 28th 2009 at 1:38pm
view wrenagain's profile

COMPLETELY convinced.
i've been using the keeper for about eight years now.
as wrenagain says, it's the best thing ever.

posted by lightdaughter on September 28th 2009 at 1:53pm
view lightdaughter's profile

the keeper is the best thing ever.
especially if you travel... many undeveloped countries also don't have tampons available and you don't have to bring any with you--just the cup!

sometimes i can't believe people don't use one!

posted by caiti on September 28th 2009 at 1:59pm
view caiti's profile

I switched a few years ago, and I LOVE my Mooncup! My sister is creeped out by it, though. I think a lot of women think this is a really kind of "icky" option, but if you're using tampons sans applicator, this isn't any different, really. If you only use pads, this'll take some getting used to, but it is SERIOUSLY worth it.

posted by deliriumsama on September 28th 2009 at 2:08pm
view deliriumsama's profile

My sister gave me a divacup for my birthday and honestly if she hadn't I wouldn't have tried it. It works well after you figure out how to put it in so that there's a seal. I only wish there was a more discrete way to clean it in public. : ) Oh well, if everyone used it probably wouldn't be as awkward.

posted by juice on September 28th 2009 at 2:27pm
view juice's profile

LOVE the diva cup, never going back!

posted by elbow on September 28th 2009 at 2:55pm
view elbow's profile

tampons and pads have been linked to HPV, or at least thats what i recall reading. non-organic tampons and pads, that is.

posted by deeboyayay on September 28th 2009 at 5:52pm
view deeboyayay's profile

It takes a few times to get used to it, but really, far superior!

posted by supapfunk on September 28th 2009 at 6:43pm
view supapfunk's profile

If you have had TSS, do not use a menstrual cup. As with any gynecological concern, please consult your physician.

posted by Khürt Williams on September 28th 2009 at 7:27pm
view Khürt Williams's profile

I haven't used disposables since I was 17, 12 years ago. I had a keeper for about 8 or 9 years and then bought a Diva Cup. I also use washable cotton pads, mostly at night. I'm still on my first set of those. I doubt they will ever wear out. And it's really not a big deal to was them.

~MrsFoss

posted by MrsFoss on September 28th 2009 at 7:35pm
view MrsFoss's profile

"tampons and pads have been linked to HPV, or at least thats what i recall reading. non-organic tampons and pads, that is."

That makes no sense - HPV is a virus. You can't possibly catch it from a tampon or pad unless someone has wiped a wart on it.

posted by Rebekkap on September 28th 2009 at 7:42pm
view Rebekkap's profile

One of my fellow nurses brought me up to speed on the Diva cup thing. I tried it, and loved it. It took a couple times inserting it to get used to it, but it's really way more comfortable than tampons.

I don't think, as the other poster indicated, that TSS is any more likely with that or anything else. Common sense being the rule here. I have found my docs don't know what they are, and I end up educating them.

What I like the best about it, is that after I learned how to use it, it was really more comfortable. By a large margin.

posted by imake1tgirl on September 28th 2009 at 9:35pm
view imake1tgirl's profile

I absolutely love my Divacup but I have to say that, after 18 months or so, I STILL have not mastered the technique completely...

posted by Ostendaise on September 29th 2009 at 7:00am
view Ostendaise's profile

i started with a divacup two-and-a-half years ago and now have a mooncup and i'd never go back to my pre-cup days. they're amazing.

posted by chewbecca on September 29th 2009 at 9:31am
view chewbecca's profile

My medical history form asked me if I used pads or tampons-- I had to draw a box for neither! I also got to explain to my gyn why I use the Divacup (she may have already known, but I was happy to do so). Thank you Re-nest for making this post!

posted by alysaaria on September 29th 2009 at 9:58am
view alysaaria's profile

My knitting group recommended the Diva Cup to me about a year ago, and I couldn't be happier. We're all ridiculously enthusiastic about our cups in my knitting group. :)

posted by bloo_mountain on September 29th 2009 at 11:18am
view bloo_mountain's profile

I got one of these about 10 years ago and was never able to use it--I found the process of putting it in very uncomfortable and difficult (the brand is Keeper, if I recall). I have tried it several times over the years since I got it, always with the same results.

posted by hyzen on September 29th 2009 at 11:42am
view hyzen's profile

hyzen, from what i understand you might want to try a divacup instead. the keeper is made of a less flexible material as i understand and its rigidity makes it more difficult to use??

posted by DahliaCactus on September 30th 2009 at 6:27pm
view DahliaCactus's profile

I love my Diva Cup and would never go back. Learning to use it was comparable to learning to use tampons for the first time. And although I am a generally squeamish person, I find this far less icky than pads.

For cleaning it in public-- you don't have to clean it with water every time. The instructions that come with it say that you can clean it with toilet paper, then wash it thoroughly the next time you empty it. Just wash your hands before handling it. I have done this several times with no problems. Since you can wear it for up to 12 hours, though, I rarely have to change it in public unless it's maybe day 1 or day 2 of a very heavy cycle.

My mother used to tell me about the trials of the "belts and pins" days. After using the Diva Cup I feel that way about tampons and pads. They are antiquated and uncomfortable, and this is a much better solution.

posted by matchbookhymnal on September 30th 2009 at 9:39pm
view matchbookhymnal's profile

And by "in public" I mean in a public restroom. Cause, uh, anything else would be very disturbing.

posted by matchbookhymnal on September 30th 2009 at 9:41pm
view matchbookhymnal's profile

I have one and I love it. Women need to get over the "gross" factor of having a period.

posted by Melissa A. on October 2nd 2009 at 9:24am
view Melissa A.'s profile

I tried the Instead soft cup when it first came out. I liked the idea of it, but it was disposable (and messy), so it was really no better than using tampons. I've been thinking about trying the Divacup, but I keep going back and forth. I'm ok with the ick factor involved, but I'm concerned about using it at work. I teach and my classes are 90 minutes long, with 5 minutes in between. There's really no room for flexibility if something goes wrong or it takes a few minutes to clean in the bathroom. As much as I hate them, I just feel safer with tampons.

posted by LitNerd on October 4th 2009 at 9:38am
view LitNerd's profile

It's been five years now that I've switched to organic cotton washable pads. They are still all in great shape, and I can't imagine using "regular" products.

I started using those sea sponges, but they weren't ideal. When I saw a DivaCup on sale at Whole Foods, I grabbed it. It works perfectly for me, and I switch between that and my LunaPads.

I guess some people are grossed out by that idea, but I think bleached dri weave who knows what in a box with adhesive strips is gross.

posted by Waldorf Modern on October 13th 2009 at 12:48pm
view Waldorf Modern's profile